{
  "vocabulary": "aesthetary.public-evidence/1.0",
  "source": "docs/remediation/phase-2/PUBLIC-EVIDENCE-VOCABULARY.md",
  "kinds": {
    "documented": {
      "text": "Documented",
      "definition": "A source states it, and the source is attached to the claim."
    },
    "seen": {
      "text": "Seen in the work",
      "definition": "Observed in real artefacts that someone inspected."
    },
    "graded": {
      "text": "Graded by our research brief",
      "definition": "A research brief graded this documented, but no source is attached yet. A grade is not a source."
    },
    "catalogue": {
      "text": "From our catalogue entry",
      "definition": "Carried over from Aesthetary's original catalogue entry. The reasoning behind it was never recorded."
    },
    "reading": {
      "text": "Our reading",
      "definition": "Aesthetary's conclusion from the material. No single source says it."
    },
    "translation": {
      "text": "Web translation",
      "definition": "How Aesthetary applies the language on screen. Not something the aesthetic itself specified."
    },
    "not_part": {
      "text": "Not part of the aesthetic",
      "definition": "An accessibility floor or general current practice that would apply to any build."
    }
  },
  "marks": {
    "attached": {
      "text": "Source attached",
      "definition": "support cited: a verified source, the claim located in it"
    },
    "unverified": {
      "text": "Source not yet verified",
      "definition": "support cited_unverified: the source is unresolved or metadata-missing, or the claim was not found at the locator"
    },
    "none": {
      "text": "No source attached",
      "definition": "support graded_unlinked or none, on a claim whose kind implies one could exist"
    },
    "disputed": {
      "text": "disputed",
      "definition": "the claim is contested: against-evidence is attached (support.against). Counter-evidence is never support."
    }
  },
  "area_states": {
    "specified": {
      "text": "Specified"
    },
    "open_by_finding": {
      "text": "Left open",
      "definition": "researched and found free"
    },
    "not_canonically_specified": {
      "text": "Not specified by the source",
      "definition": "the source medium never addressed it; a translation may follow"
    },
    "not_applicable": {
      "text": "Does not apply"
    },
    "excluded": {
      "text": "Ruled out"
    },
    "not_established": {
      "text": "Not researched yet"
    },
    "open_question": {
      "text": "Open question"
    },
    "withheld": {
      "text": "Withheld"
    }
  },
  "importance": {
    "core": {
      "text": "Core"
    },
    "supporting": {
      "text": "Supporting"
    }
  },
  "strengths": {
    "necessary": {
      "text": "Necessary"
    },
    "strong": {
      "text": "Strong"
    },
    "common": {
      "text": "Common"
    },
    "optional": {
      "text": "Optional"
    },
    "unreliable": {
      "text": "Unreliable"
    },
    "note": "Necessary (remove it and it is not this) · Strong · Common (occurs often; defines nothing) · Optional · Unreliable (can occur; does not define it). Where Aesthetary set the tier, the strength carries “our ranking”."
  },
  "research_lines": {
    "partly_sourced": {
      "text": "Partly sourced"
    },
    "graded_not_sourced": {
      "text": "Graded, not yet sourced"
    },
    "not_researched": {
      "text": "Not yet researched"
    }
  },
  "owed": {
    "research": {
      "text": "No source has been examined for this yet."
    },
    "judgment": {
      "text": "A judgment on the material the record already holds is still owed."
    },
    "ontology": {
      "text": "The record model has no value for this yet."
    }
  },
  "states": {
    "resolved": "the value is on the record",
    "owed": "the value is not yet decided; `owed` says what kind of work is owed",
    "withheld": "the value is held for cultural review and is not published",
    "none": "the record has no such value"
  }
}